Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
  • Home
  • Hot Topics
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Big Law
  • Small Law
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
No Result
View All Result
Home Hot Topics

Appeals court says judge may be ‘in the wrong line of work,’ vacates sentence for a second time

Daily Legal Briefing by Daily Legal Briefing
February 10, 2022
in Hot Topics
0
Appeals court says judge may be ‘in the wrong line of work,’ vacates sentence for a second time
4
SHARES
32
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


  1. Home
  2. Daily News
  3. Appeals court says judge may be ‘in the wrong…

Judiciary

Appeals court says judge may be ‘in the wrong line of work,’ vacates sentence for a second time

By Debra Cassens Weiss

February 9, 2022, 2:41 pm CST

Michigan gavel

Image from Shutterstock.

The Michigan Court of Appeals has once again vacated a sentence imposed by a Michigan judge in a fatal stabbing case, citing his “blatant refusal” to follow precedent that bars judges from considering acquitted conduct in sentencing.

The appeals court said a different judge would sentence the defendant, Dawn Marie Dixon-Bey, who fatally stabbed her boyfriend on Valentine’s Day in 2015.

The Washington Post, the Associated Press and Fox 47 News have coverage of the Feb. 1 decision.

The judge, Judge John McBain of Jackson County, Michigan, refused to impose a sentence in the guidelines range of 12 to 20 years in prison both times that he sentenced the defendant.

Jurors had found Dixon-Bey guilty of second-degree murder.

“It could not be plainer that the jury acquitted defendant of first-degree murder because it found that the element of premeditation was not established,” the Michigan Court of Appeals said.

Yet McBain sentenced Dixon-Bey as though she had been found guilty of first-degree murder, the appeals court said. Indeed, McBain declared that Dixon-Bey committed “a cold blooded, premeditated stabbing,” even though premeditation wasn’t established.

The first time, McBain sentenced Dixon-Bey to 35 to 70 years in prison, saying she “brutally murdered” the victim “in cold blood.” After the appeals court vacated that sentence, McBain sentenced the woman to 30 to 70 years in prison.

Between the 2016 and 2020 sentencings, the Michigan Supreme Court decided Michigan v. Beck, which held that a trial judge can’t use acquitted conduct in crafting a sentence.

The appeals court said judges aren’t obligated to agree with decisions by higher courts, but they must comply with them.

“If a trial judge is unable to follow the law as determined by a higher appellate court, the trial judge is in the wrong line of work,” the Michigan Court of Appeals said.

The appeals court also said McBain deprived Dixon-Bey of her right to speak during sentencing. McBain interrupted Dixon-Bey, asked how she took the victim’s life, and then answered the question for her.

“With two stab wounds directly to the heart, right?” McBain asked.

The appeals court said McBain’s commentary indicated that he wished to provide his own testimony, “seemingly in the pursuit of a sentencing decision [he] had already decided upon.”

“Allocution is the defendant’s opportunity to address the court, not the court’s opportunity to conduct an interrogation or deliver a lecture,” the Michigan Court of Appeals said.

McBain has previously been in the news for helping tackle a defendant who resisted courtroom handcuffing, for aggressive questioning of defense witnesses that resulted in a murder retrial, and for ordering a defense lawyer to be locked up during a lunch break after refusing instructions to sit down.

McBain didn’t comment on the Dixon-Bey case when contacted by the Washington Post and Fox 47 News.





Click to Read Original Article

Previous Post

Biglaw Firm Announces Bonuses, Delayed Raises During Salary War

Next Post

Law Firms Should Give Employees An Actual Choice About Returning To Offices

Daily Legal Briefing

Daily Legal Briefing

Related Posts

Judge imposes default judgment against former Littler Mendelson client for ‘subversive approach to discovery’
Hot Topics

5th Circuit tells lawyer it is ‘often advisable to read the court’s orders,’ upholds $1,250 sanction

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Law firm’s managing partner had a ‘fixation’ with employee surveillance, wiretap suit says
Hot Topics

Law firm’s managing partner had a ‘fixation’ with employee surveillance, wiretap suit says

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Law school applicants are down, for now, for the first time since 2018
Hot Topics

Following a boost in 2021, national average score for February 2022 MBE drops

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Google violated its ‘don’t be evil’ code when it fired 3 outspoken employees abiding by mandate, suit says
Hot Topics

Google’s ‘privileged’ email labeling, said to prevent lawsuit disclosure, was ‘eyebrow raising,’ judge says

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 11, 2022
New law allows this state’s judges to personally solicit campaign donations; ethics opinion adds wrinkle
Hot Topics

New law allows this state’s judges to personally solicit campaign donations; ethics opinion adds wrinkle

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 11, 2022
Next Post
Law Firms Should Give Employees An Actual Choice About Returning To Offices

Law Firms Should Give Employees An Actual Choice About Returning To Offices

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Premium Content

Lawyers Sometimes Cannot Trust Other Attorneys To Complete Legal Tasks

Lawyers Sometimes Cannot Trust Other Attorneys To Complete Legal Tasks

November 9, 2022
Six ways firms can win with legal technology in an uncertain market

Six ways firms can win with legal technology in an uncertain market

June 28, 2022
Nonlawyer-owned alternative legal services provider receives Arizona’s approval to integrate with a law firm

Nonlawyer-owned alternative legal services provider receives Arizona’s approval to integrate with a law firm

January 14, 2022

Browse by Category

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

About US

Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing.
Online coverage of breaking legal news and current law headlines from around the US. Top stories, videos, insight, and in-depth analysis.

Categories

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

Recent Updates

  • How Blockchain Technology is Changing the Legal Industry
  • Women in Law Are Driving an Entirely New Practice Model
  • 3 Professionals You Need to Have on Your Radar

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

No Result
View All Result
  • Contact Us
  • Home

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?