Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
  • Home
  • Hot Topics
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Big Law
  • Small Law
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Beyond Capitalism, but not Communism

Daily Legal Briefing by Daily Legal Briefing
October 18, 2022
in Business
0
Beyond Capitalism, but not Communism
4
SHARES
36
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


People argue endlessly about which of the Big Two economic systems is better and fairer, but there’s more out there besides Capitalism and Communism.


Having witnessed a great many online discussions rapidly decay in a spittle-flecked, frenetic combination of ignorance and strong emotion due to the absence of any concept of the various economic systems that have existed through space and time, aside from the Big Two (of course), it is this author’s fervent hope that endeavoring to shed light upon such systems, even in an incomplete and partial way, will assist the public imagination and improve our national conversation, leading to more creative economic outcomes. Many of the loudest American voices seem attached to minds which can only think in binary terms: white/black, Democrat/Republican, Capitalist/Communist, freedom/slavery, good/evil. How much more there is, for those who care to see! Beyond capitalism lies more than just “it must be Communism,” and it’s worth exploring ideas that have served other human societies in order to conceive new systems for our future.

First, however, it is prudent to come to adequate agreement as to what those first two words mean.

These days, it seems that both words – Capitalism and Communism – have come to mean something other than ways of organizing an economy and distributing the goods produced therein. Capitalism, then, relates to an economy based upon the accumulation and investment of particularly large piles of wealth to generate economic returns, a meaning utterly lost when the term has been watered down to something more akin to “freedom” or “warm, good, happy feelings of positivity.” Capitalism isn’t the same as simply having markets or engaging in trade. Although elements of capitalism are evident in, say, the forbidden medieval practice of usury (lending money to be repaid with interest), it really came into its own with such innovations as the chartered East India Company in the 18th century, which began the process of ravaging the subcontinent for private profit.

Likewise, “communism” has come to mean “bad, evil things that inspire feelings of unhappiness” rather than “an economic system in which the major means of production are owned and controlled by the public,” with the aim of a classless, stateless society. In 20th century practice, this has often meant a state-controlled economy, though today’s anarchist-communists envision independent, egalitarian communities managing their own economic needs. Doubtless, private owners of capital would prefer that the idea of public collectivization of wealth be widely associated with grim, fearful feelings (similar to the way many economically disadvantaged poors feel about the word “capitalism” these days), but such emotional redefinition does little to advance the worthy goal of creating an economy that works for as many people as possible (and, importantly, doesn’t destroy the natural world on which our lives depend).

Vintage photograph of a man with bushy, white hair and beard, seated, wearing formal clothes.
Karl Marx, acknowledged father of revolutionary communist theory. Photo by John Jabez Edwin Mayall, colored by Olga Shirnina, courtesy of Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 2.0

So, beyond capitalism and communism, what is there? How else could an economy possibly be organized?

Perhaps the oldest system is the gift economy. When humans lived together in small bands, often at least partially nomadic, one depended upon one’s tribe to live. Food was shared; there were social rules about how to parcel out a hunter’s kill. Those who accumulated too much or acted too greedily may have been mocked and humbled by their peers, ensuring that resources were spread widely. Gifts of food, tools, or other objects were regularly exchanged, and while everyone knew the score, not reciprocating similarly at some point was shameful. If you’ve ever attended a seed swap, a supper club, or even Christmas morning, you’ve taken part in a gift economy, where the best way to invest one’s excess is in one’s friends.

Later came the palace economy. Greater control of a larger population enabled central elites to organize the production and distribution of goods. Land and materials may be provided, such as in the Inca Empire, where different villages were assigned different kinds of production. Finished goods would be collected at a central location, such as a palace or temple (since state and religious power were mingled, a condition some among us would prefer even now). Authorities would then redistribute the goods as they saw fit, whether around the kingdom to those that needed them, as trade goods with other polities, gifts to form alliances, financing a military, or what have you. A similar modern equivalent might be North Korea’s version of state communism, where the government decides what grains farmers are to grow, and redistributes whatever grain is produced back to the people “according to need” (and availability).

You likely heard about the next one in school: feudalism, the dominant economic system of medieval Europe, among other regions. Land (the most important means of production) was owned by the monarch, who lent control of it to the nobility in exchange for the promise of military support in war. Nobility lent smaller parcels to knights, who promised to fight. Knights then provided peasantry with land, in exchange for labor and a share of produce. The details and customs varied from place to place, of course, and the Church complicated it even more, but however hierarchal and oppressive, feudalism was a relatively efficient answer to the circumstances of the time. Nowadays, we don’t have to look far for the modern equivalent of a low-mobility landless underclass who serve their more wealthy ‘betters.’

Indigenous tribes of the salmon-rich Pacific Northwest devised the potlatch economy. Any chief who wanted to remain in that position would do so by ordering a potlatch ceremony and inviting outsiders to attend. By commanding as much production of feast foods and gifts as that tribe could afford, and giving it away in abundance during the ceremony, the chief could earn prestige as the richest and most generous, the rightful big man. As in the gift economy, a mental tally was kept and reciprocity expected, with any shortfall resulting in the loss of political prestige. Organized as a way of allocating political power, it was also an effective way of distributing goods from those with more to those with less.

Distributism is a lesser-known economic philosophy with its roots in Catholicism. Rather than the means of production being concentrated in the hands of the rich, or run by a government bureaucracy, the main goal of distributism is to spread the ownership of property and the means of production as widely as possible. This could mean a great many mom-and-pop shops, worker-owned co-ops, small diverse farms, and independent contractors. Sure, the lack of vast accumulations of capital would mean fewer giant corporations, but that price might be worth paying if it means that everyone had the means to sustain themselves.

Socialism has become as emotionally loaded a term as capitalism or communism, but what is it really? Opinions vary, but in the democratic socialist, Nordic model held up by the likes of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, there’s still a capitalist, market economy. Some of the most essential human needs, which aren’t always met by the market, are simply made available alongside and outside of it, funded by public taxation (that is, skimming a bit of the productivity off of a capitalist economy in order to make it serve more people). Major examples would be the British National Health Service, social security payments to the elderly, or state-owned banks that do not need to operate at a profit because their mission is more human-centric.

As you can see, beyond capitalism and communism lies an impressive array of other ways to live. In practice, no single economic system takes care of all needs perfectly. We live in such a mix, where we may work for a capitalist, receive food assistance benefits (SNAP) to subsidize an insufficient wage, trade baby clothes with a moms’ group, and take advantage of a community garden plot or CSA share.

Looking around, however, it’s easy to see that the dominant form of American capitalism isn’t working for everyone. There are homeless people and people-less homes. Vast amounts of food are wasted, yet there are hungry people. We’re destroying the landbase and creating mountains of trash. Increasingly, people are impatient to find a better way, although their imaginations usually settle into two opposing and circularly-arguing camps. It’s a situation that could desperately use an injection of fresh ideas, because the system is failing. Sooner than later, we’ll have to figure out how to produce and distribute what people need, beyond capitalism. Let’s start now.

Related: Distributism: An Old/New Economic Answer

Sources:

History of Capitalism
Lessons for capitalism from the East India Company
Communism
Anarchist communism – an introduction
The Gift Economy
Why Envy Might Be Good for Us
TOTW: Palace Economy
The Origins of the “Temple-Economy” as seen in the Light of Prehistoric Evidence
Famine and the Future of Food Security in North Korea [PDF]
Feudalism
The Feudal Society in Medieval Europe
Neofeudalism: The End of Capitalism?
The Potlatch as Fractional Reserve Banking [PDF]
An Introduction to Distributism
Distributism
Neither Capitalism nor Socialism: A Third Alternative
Capitalism Isn’t Working. But What Would a Viable Socialist System Look Like?
The freedom lover’s case for the welfare state



Click to Read Original Article

Previous Post

SOX Turns 20: Auditing and Accounting Impacts and a Look Forward

Next Post

Blockchain: The Future Of The Legal Profession

Daily Legal Briefing

Daily Legal Briefing

The latest breaking legal news from across World all in one place.

Related Posts

Delving into the Complex World of Insurance Claims
Business

Delving into the Complex World of Insurance Claims

by Daily Legal Briefing
October 3, 2023
How to Set Competitive Rates and Fees for Your Law Firm’s Services
Business

How to Set Competitive Rates and Fees for Your Law Firm’s Services

by Daily Legal Briefing
October 3, 2023
Groundbreaking New Book by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Brian Hooker Ph.D. Presents Vaccine Safety Data Suppressed by Government and Mainstream Medicine
Business

Groundbreaking New Book by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Brian Hooker Ph.D. Presents Vaccine Safety Data Suppressed by Government and Mainstream Medicine

by Daily Legal Briefing
September 23, 2023
How Technology Helps Lawyers Win Cases
Business

CARET Legal Introduces AI-Enabled “Quick Summary” Feature to Maximize Productivity of Attorneys

by Daily Legal Briefing
September 22, 2023
Wolters Kluwer Named a Leader in Enterprise Legal Management Software by IDC MarketScape
Business

Wolters Kluwer Named a Leader in Enterprise Legal Management Software by IDC MarketScape

by Daily Legal Briefing
September 22, 2023
Next Post
What Does 2022 Have In Store For Blockchain, Crypto Assets, DeFi, And NFTs?

Blockchain: The Future Of The Legal Profession

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Premium Content

Trend Alert: Lawyers Who Won’t Go Back To The Office Without Their Dogs

Trend Alert: Lawyers Who Won’t Go Back To The Office Without Their Dogs

February 2, 2022
5 Ways Attorneys Can Deal with Changes Occurring in the Legal Profession

Effective Ways to Use Technology to Grow Your Law Firm

May 17, 2023
The Modern In-House Lawyer’s Guide: Better Contract Content, Alternative Fee Arrangements, And Early Stage Companies

Some Clients Like The Trappings Of A Larger Law Firm

September 22, 2022

Browse by Category

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

About US

Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing.
Online coverage of breaking legal news and current law headlines from around the US. Top stories, videos, insight, and in-depth analysis.

Categories

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

Recent Updates

  • Finding Purpose in Your In-House Role
  • Law Student Arrested For Beheading Fiancée
  • Introducing ‘UpLevel View’: A Podcast On All Things Legal Ops! 

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

No Result
View All Result
  • Contact Us
  • Home

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?