Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
  • Home
  • Hot Topics
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Big Law
  • Small Law
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
No Result
View All Result
Home Hot Topics

‘Opening the door’ rule violated defendant’s rights under Sixth Amendment’s confrontation clause, SCOTUS says

Daily Legal Briefing by Daily Legal Briefing
January 21, 2022
in Hot Topics
0
‘Opening the door’ rule violated defendant’s rights under Sixth Amendment’s confrontation clause, SCOTUS says
4
SHARES
32
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


  1. Home
  2. Daily News
  3. ‘Opening the door’ rule violated defendant’s…

U.S. Supreme Court

‘Opening the door’ rule violated defendant’s rights under Sixth Amendment’s confrontation clause, SCOTUS says

By Debra Cassens Weiss

January 20, 2022, 10:51 am CST

evidence and magnifying glass

Image from Shutterstock.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Thursday that a New York’s “opening the door” rule violated a defendant’s rights under the Sixth Amendment’s confrontation clause.

The “opening the door” rule allows use of otherwise inadmissible evidence when trial testimony creates a misleading impression and opens the door to rebuttal.

The high court ruled 8-1 for Darrell Hemphill, who sought to exclude evidence about a plea allocution entered by a defendant who was now out of the country. Hemphill had contended that the other defendant was the shooter whose stray 9 mm bullet killed a 2-year-old child in a passing car during a street fight in the Bronx, New York, in 2006.

The other defendant had pleaded guilty to criminal possession of a .357 revolver after a prosecution for the child’s murder ended in a mistrial. During a search of the other defendant’s apartment, police had found a 9 mm cartridge and ammunition for a .357 revolver.

At Hemphill’s trial for the same murder, the defense introduced testimony about police finding the 9 mm cartridge on the nightstand of the other defendant. In response, the state sought to introduce the other defendant’s plea allocution asserting that he had possessed a .357 revolver at the scene of the shooting.

A judge allowed the evidence, and Hemphill was found guilty of second-degree murder.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote the majority opinion.

“Hemphill did not forfeit his confrontation right merely by making the plea allocution arguably relevant to his theory of defense,” she wrote.

“The confrontation clause requires that the reliability and veracity of the evidence against a criminal defendant be tested by cross-examination, not determined by a trial court. The trial court’s admission of unconfronted testimonial hearsay over Hemphill’s objection, on the view that it was reasonably necessary to correct Hemphill’s misleading argument, violated that fundamental guarantee.”

Justice Clarence Thomas dissented and said the confrontation clause issue was not properly before the court because the New York Court of Appeals didn’t expressly consider the claim.

Hat tip to SCOTUSblog.

See also:

ABAJournal.com: “Can opening-the-door evidence doctrine violate the confrontation clause? SCOTUS will decide”





Click to Read Original Article

Previous Post

These Biglaw Salary Raises Were ‘Inevitable,’ So When Will The First Firm Match?

Next Post

Can lawyers who are natural pessimists learn to channel optimism? Speaker at well-being conference says it’s time to try

Daily Legal Briefing

Daily Legal Briefing

Related Posts

Judge imposes default judgment against former Littler Mendelson client for ‘subversive approach to discovery’
Hot Topics

5th Circuit tells lawyer it is ‘often advisable to read the court’s orders,’ upholds $1,250 sanction

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Law firm’s managing partner had a ‘fixation’ with employee surveillance, wiretap suit says
Hot Topics

Law firm’s managing partner had a ‘fixation’ with employee surveillance, wiretap suit says

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Law school applicants are down, for now, for the first time since 2018
Hot Topics

Following a boost in 2021, national average score for February 2022 MBE drops

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Google violated its ‘don’t be evil’ code when it fired 3 outspoken employees abiding by mandate, suit says
Hot Topics

Google’s ‘privileged’ email labeling, said to prevent lawsuit disclosure, was ‘eyebrow raising,’ judge says

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 11, 2022
New law allows this state’s judges to personally solicit campaign donations; ethics opinion adds wrinkle
Hot Topics

New law allows this state’s judges to personally solicit campaign donations; ethics opinion adds wrinkle

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 11, 2022
Next Post
Institute for Well-Being in Law will host first virtual conference later this month

Can lawyers who are natural pessimists learn to channel optimism? Speaker at well-being conference says it’s time to try

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Premium Content

Trump-appointed judge blasts 9th Circuit’s ’embarrassing’ immigration rulings

Trump-appointed judge blasts 9th Circuit’s ’embarrassing’ immigration rulings

November 24, 2021
Law School Dean Wants ChatGPT Taught In Legal Research & Writing Classes

Law School Dean Wants ChatGPT Taught In Legal Research & Writing Classes

January 12, 2023
Allow Me To Reintroduce Myself

Allow Me To Reintroduce Myself

September 29, 2023

Browse by Category

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

About US

Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing.
Online coverage of breaking legal news and current law headlines from around the US. Top stories, videos, insight, and in-depth analysis.

Categories

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

Recent Updates

  • Law Student Arrested For Beheading Fiancée
  • Introducing ‘UpLevel View’: A Podcast On All Things Legal Ops! 
  • Fried Frank’s Chair Steps Down After 10 Years, Ushering In New Leaders

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

No Result
View All Result
  • Contact Us
  • Home

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?