Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
  • Home
  • Hot Topics
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Big Law
  • Small Law
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing
No Result
View All Result
Home Hot Topics

Supreme Court will decide whether web designer has free speech right to refuse service for same-sex weddings

Daily Legal Briefing by Daily Legal Briefing
February 23, 2022
in Hot Topics
0
Supreme Court will decide whether web designer has free speech right to refuse service for same-sex weddings
4
SHARES
33
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


  1. Home
  2. Daily News
  3. Supreme Court will decide whether web designer…

U.S. Supreme Court

Supreme Court will decide whether web designer has free speech right to refuse service for same-sex weddings

By Debra Cassens Weiss

February 22, 2022, 2:16 pm CST

The U.S. Supreme Court has taken up the case of a web designer who contends that she has a First Amendment right to refuse to provide online service for same-sex weddings.

The Supreme Court said Tuesday it would decide whether applying public accommodations law to compel an artist to speak or stay silent violates the free speech clause of the First Amendment.

The high court declined to address other issues regarding the web designer’s religious rights to refuse service under the First Amendment’s free exercise clause.

The web designer, Lorie Smith, is represented by the conservative Christian nonprofit group Alliance Defending Freedom. She plans to expand her services to offer wedding website design services that promote her understanding of marriage as between one man and one woman, according to her cert petition.

She would also like to post an online statement explaining that she can only post messages that are consistent with her religious convictions.

Alliance Defending Freedom had also represented Jack Phillips, who refused to bake a cake for a same-sex wedding on religious grounds. The Supreme Court had ruled narrowly for Phillips in Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, holding in June 2018 that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission had violated his rights by showing hostility to his religious explanation.

Smith’s case is 303 Creative v. Elenis.

The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at Denver had ruled against Smith in July 2021. The appeals court found that the Colorado law did not violate the First Amendment when it required public accommodations to provide equal access to services regardless of sexual orientation.

The appeals court acknowledged that Smith’s websites are pure speech implicating her unique creative talents. But Colorado “has a compelling interest in protecting both the dignity interests of members of marginalized groups and their material interests in accessing the commercial marketplace,” the court said.

Smith’s cert petition says the 10th Circuit decision took the “remarkable” stance that the government may force an artist to produce messages that “violate her conscience.” The Colorado law requires Smith to create websites celebrating same-sex marriages and bans her from posting her online statement, the petition says.

Colorado’s brief opposing cert says Colorado’s public accommodations law is “a straightforward regulation of commercial conduct” that satisfies constitutional requirements.

“Additionally, even if a business offers expressive products and services, the message communicated by those products and services is attributable to the customer, not the business,” the brief says.

The SCOTUSblog case page for 303 Creative v. Elenis is here.

Hat tip to Law360, which covered the cert grant here.





Click to Read Original Article

Previous Post

ABA legal ed section plans to send another diversity standard, revisions for remote learning requirements to HOD

Next Post

Findings From The Litera-Pitchbook Venture Capital Report

Daily Legal Briefing

Daily Legal Briefing

Related Posts

Judge imposes default judgment against former Littler Mendelson client for ‘subversive approach to discovery’
Hot Topics

5th Circuit tells lawyer it is ‘often advisable to read the court’s orders,’ upholds $1,250 sanction

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Law firm’s managing partner had a ‘fixation’ with employee surveillance, wiretap suit says
Hot Topics

Law firm’s managing partner had a ‘fixation’ with employee surveillance, wiretap suit says

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Law school applicants are down, for now, for the first time since 2018
Hot Topics

Following a boost in 2021, national average score for February 2022 MBE drops

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 12, 2022
Google violated its ‘don’t be evil’ code when it fired 3 outspoken employees abiding by mandate, suit says
Hot Topics

Google’s ‘privileged’ email labeling, said to prevent lawsuit disclosure, was ‘eyebrow raising,’ judge says

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 11, 2022
New law allows this state’s judges to personally solicit campaign donations; ethics opinion adds wrinkle
Hot Topics

New law allows this state’s judges to personally solicit campaign donations; ethics opinion adds wrinkle

by Daily Legal Briefing
April 11, 2022
Next Post
Findings From The Litera-Pitchbook Venture Capital Report

Findings From The Litera-Pitchbook Venture Capital Report

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Premium Content

Johnny Depp Dating Lawyer Who Represented Him In Defamation Trial

Johnny Depp Dating Lawyer Who Represented Him In Defamation Trial

September 23, 2022
Sally Yates-Led Investigation Finds ‘Systemic’ Sexual Misconduct And Abuse In Women’s Soccer

Sally Yates-Led Investigation Finds ‘Systemic’ Sexual Misconduct And Abuse In Women’s Soccer

October 5, 2022
Biglaw Firm Matches Davis Polk Salary Scale For Associates

Biglaw Firm Matches Davis Polk Salary Scale For Associates

March 1, 2022

Browse by Category

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

About US

Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines | Daily Legal Briefing.
Online coverage of breaking legal news and current law headlines from around the US. Top stories, videos, insight, and in-depth analysis.

Categories

  • Big Law
  • Breaking
  • Business
  • Hot Topics
  • Law School
  • Legal Tech
  • Small Law

Recent Updates

  • Former Biglaw Attorney Suspended From Practice For Insider Trading
  • This Biglaw Firm Is Expanding By Hiring A Boatload Of Lateral Partners
  • Lawyers Should Nurture Smaller Clients

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

No Result
View All Result
  • Contact Us
  • Home

© 2021 Daily Legal Briefing | Breaking Legal News & Current Law Headlines

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?